Alpha Centauri 2

Community => Recreation Commons => Destination: Alpha Centauri => Topic started by: Buster's Uncle on January 26, 2015, 03:03:47 pm

Title: Elon Musk debunks electric space rockets after Simpsons lampooning
Post by: Buster's Uncle on January 26, 2015, 03:03:47 pm

Elon Musk debunks electric space rockets after Simpsons lampooning
The inventor gave Springfield electric cars — but that won't work in space
The Verge
By James Vincent on January 26, 2015 05:09 am



After Elon Musk appeared on the Simpsons last night and jetted off at the end of the episode in his Dragon spacecraft, Lisa points out that "for a man who likes electric cars he sure burns a lot of rocket fuel." Musk apparently heard this parting shot as a slight against his technological prowess, and took to Twitter to point out why electricity will never get people off the planet:

Quote

(https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/420314816444502016/xj5TnUsx_normal.jpeg) Elon Musk        ✔   @elonmusk  Follow
If u saw @TheSimpsons and wonder why @SpaceX doesn't use an electric rocket to reach orbit, it is cuz that is impossible

10:30 PM - 25 Jan 2015

2,514 Retweets   3,933 favorites    Reply Retweet

Musk goes on to explain: "Reason is Newton's Third Law. In vacuum, there is nothing to "push" against. You must react against ejected mass … Ion thrusters are great, but have extremely tiny force (photon thruster even less). Must have more thrust than weight or you don't go up." He also notes that another futuristic trope for getting off the planet — the space elevator — still needs a lot more research into the raw materials before it'll actually work:

Quote

(https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/420314816444502016/xj5TnUsx_normal.jpeg) Elon Musk        ✔   @elonmusk  Follow
And pls don't ask me about space elevators  until someone at least builds a carbon nanotube structure longer than a footbridge

10:45 PM - 25 Jan 2015

1,769 Retweets   3,160 favorites    Reply Retweet

It wasn't just electric rockets that were suggested in the Simpsons though. Musk arrives in the town as an inventor out of ideas but is soon inspired by Homer’s free-form rambling and ends up overhauling the nuclear power plant and installing electric, self-driving cars in every home. There are gags about violin-playing quadcopters, self-packing luggage, and even a working hyperloop (although it's no monorail). The Simpsons - Monorail (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xhpO_WcR_jE#)

Overall, Musk is given the usual celebrity treatment: there's a couple of good-humoured jokes about his status as world's best inventor ("You’re the guy who put wheels on luggage!?"), but it's mostly just compliments dressed up as criticisms. His dedication to saving the planet for future generations does end up putting current Springfielders out of work however, and Musk is soon given his marching orders by Homer — blasting off once again in the Dragon spacecraft. On Twitter though, the inventor had a few more words of wisdom for those trying to get into space without rockets:

Quote

(https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/420314816444502016/xj5TnUsx_normal.jpeg) Elon Musk        ✔   @elonmusk  Follow
Final one: anything launched by a railgun (if you could ever reach ~ Mach 27) would explode upon exiting the barrel in our dense atmosphere

3:28 AM - 26 Jan 2015

363 Retweets   736 favorites    Reply Retweet

http://www.theverge.com/2015/1/26/7904897/elon-musk-debunks-electric-rockets-after-simpsons (http://www.theverge.com/2015/1/26/7904897/elon-musk-debunks-electric-rockets-after-simpsons)